Category Archives: Media

Pro-con: Have White House gripes boosted Fox?

foxnewsThe Obama White House’s inexplicable war on Fox News has magnified Fox’s stature among viewers. Far from marginalizing Fox and delegitimizing it as a news source, as intended, the feud has made more people than ever choose Fox News as their favored source of television infotainment. Fox’s ratings bumped up almost 10 percent in the two weeks after the White House decided to engage Fox News directly. And among advertisers’ favorite demographic — 25- to 54-year-olds — Fox’s ratings went up a whopping 14 percent. This is probably not the kind of change Obama voters thought they were voting for. Congratulations, Obama. You have transformed Fox into the most successful “news” channel ever. — D.K. Jamaal, Examiner.com

The breathless claim that Fox News’ ratings recently spiked thanks to the White House’s public critique is bogus hype. A detailed analysis of Nielsen ratings numbers clearly indicates that in the two weeks after the White House in mid-October sparked a media controversy by claiming Rupert Murdoch’s channel was not a legitimate news organization, Fox News’ ratings did not soar. They experienced no significant increase at all. Instead, in the two weeks after the initial verbal jousts with the White House, Fox News’ total day ratings virtually flatlined. Think about it. The unfolding controversy — which gobbled up untold hours and pages of news coverage as the Beltway press treated the dispute like a major news event — and the hubbub barely moved the ratings needle one inch in Fox News’ favor. — Eric Boehlert, Media Matters

Limbaugh, the victim

rushTalk-show host Rush Limbaugh is still playing the victim card in his failed attempt to buy a share of the St. Louis Rams. Rather than own up to his past racial comments, he blames his partners’ decision to drop him on the media’s contempt for conservatives (which, apparently, doesn’t extend to all the other NFL owners who are conservatives). Limbaugh wrote in a Wall Street Journal commentary that claims of racism are “being used to try to keep citizens who don’t share the left’s agenda from participating in the full array of opportunities this nation otherwise affords each of us.” He even likened criticism he received to attempts to smear Clarence Thomas when he was nominated for the U.S. Supreme Court. “These intimidation tactics are working and spreading, and they are a cancer on our society,” Limbaugh wrote.

Limbaugh can’t swallow own medicine

rushGiven all the times Rush Limbaugh has dragged out old quotes to demagogue liberals, it’s rich that he is so upset about being sacked in his effort to buy the St. Louis Rams over racial comments he has made over the years. “This is about the ongoing effort by the left in this country, wherever you find them, in the media, the Democrat Party, or wherever, to destroy conservatism, to prevent the mainstreaming of anyone who is prominent as a conservative,” he said Wednesday on his radio show. “Therefore, this is about the future of the United States of America and what kind of country we’re going to have.”

Whining doesn’t become Obama

obamamedia“The Obama administration really needs to get over itself.” So wrote John Nichols of the Nation, having had his fill of the White House’s official criticism of Fox News (for being too partisan and unfairly critical) and unofficial criticism of left-wing bloggers (for being insufficiently supportive). Nichols offered three facts to consider:

– “Since the founding of the republic, media outlets (the founders dismissed them as ‘damnable periodicals’) have been partisan.”

– “Presidents are supposed to rise above their own partisanship and engage with a wide range of media — even outlets that are hard on their administrations.”

– “The worst mistake a president or his administration can make is to try and ‘whip’ relatively like-minded writers and reporters into line.”

Nichols concluded: “Nothing — no attack by Glenn Beck, no blogger busting about Guantanamo — does more damage to Obama’s credibility or authority than the sense that a popular president is becoming the whiner-in-chief.”

Talk show hosts join Taliban in denouncing peace prize

limbaughFrom Eugene Robinson’s column: “The president of the United States wins the Nobel Peace Prize and Rush Limbaugh joins with the Taliban in bitterly denouncing the award? Glenn Beck has a conniption fit and demands that the president not accept what may be the world’s most prestigious honor? The Republican National Committee issues a statement sarcastically mocking our nation’s leader — elected, you will recall, by a healthy majority — as unworthy of such recognition? Why, oh why, do conservatives hate America so?”

Bosses: Don’t do as Letterman did

lettermanDavid Letterman doesn’t work for CBS, and Letterman’s production company, Worldwide Pants, has said it has a sexual harassment policy that somehow allows Letterman’s conduct. “Dave is not in violation of our policy and no one has ever raised a complaint against him,” a company spokesman told the Los Angeles Times. But the extortion attempt related to his affairs with subordinates has set off alarm bells for many lawyers. Atlanta attorney Andria Ryan told the National Law Journal that while the public hears his confession and “says, ‘Oh, what a shame for his wife, his family or his job,’ my first reaction was, ‘This is a sex harassment suit waiting to happen.’” San Francisco attorney Mark Askanas said the danger for employers is that other co-workers will see favoritism connected to the affair. “You can contain the relationship, but how do you contain the impact it has on other employees?” Askanas asked. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission saw 14,000 sexual harassment complaints in 2008, a 16 percent spike from 2007 and the first increase since 2000.

Is Beck a white Jeremiah Wright?

beck,glennColumnist Rod Dreher warned his fellow conservatives to back away from Fox News host Glenn Beck. “Beck is a white Jeremiah Wright, a crazy-pants conspiracy theorist whose worldview is rooted in the paranoid teachings of a far-right Mormon political guru named W. Cleon Skousen,” Dreher wrote. “Before signing up as a recruit in Beck’s army, conservative Becketeers had better think long and hard about where their affable leader is taking them.”

Talk radio similar to gangsta rap?

rushrapperWriter David Segal contends that “the similarities between talk radio and gangsta rap are nothing short of uncanny.” He argues: “Once you subtract gangsta rap’s enthusiasm for lawlessness — a major subtraction, to be sure — rap is among the most conservative genres of pop music. It exalts capitalism and entrepreneurship with a brio that is typically considered Republican.” Segal counts among other similarities:
– “Extolling your greatness is nearly as crucial to rap as it is to talk radio.”
– Both base credibility on claiming “to have hordes of detractors.”
– Without verbal skills, “you can’t rap and you’ll never make it as a talk radio opinion-machine.”

How many people attended 9/12 rally?

Taxpayer RallyTea party supporters are upset with the mainstream media for reporting that the number of people at the 9/12 rally in Washington, D.C., totaled in the “tens of thousands.” Some conservatives have said that the total was more than a million, and they see the disparity as another example of liberal bias. Washington Post ombudsman Andrew Alexander explains the process his newspaper went through to try to estimate the crowd size. Meanwhile, an aerial photo circulating on the Internet supposedly showing a huge crowd at the 9/12 rally turns out to be from a different rally in the 1990s.

Score one for Glenn Beck?

jones,vanSome of the reports of the resignation of White House “green jobs” adviser Van Jones (in photo) have omitted a key point. As the Washington Post reported: “Fox News Channel host Glenn Beck began the drive against Jones. Beck’s campaign grew more vitriolic after a group Jones founded in 2005, ColorofChange.org, led an advertising boycott against his show to protest Beck’s assertion that Obama is a racist.” The group’s current executive director, James Rucker, has said that Jones now has nothing to do with the group and didn’t know about the anti-Beck campaign before it began. In any case, Jones, whatever his qualifications, had become a distraction for President Obama.

Lesson for kids in Jones’ demise

magnifyingglassNew York Times columnist Tom Friedman took away a useful lesson from how Van Jones’ present job was undone by his past. On NBC’s “Meet the Press,” Friedman said: “When everyone has a cell phone, everyone’s a photographer. When everyone has access to YouTube, everyone’s a filmmaker. And when everyone’s a blogger, everyone’s a newspaper. When everyone’s a photographer, a newspaper and a filmmaker, everyone else is a public figure. Tell your kids. . . ‘be careful.’ Every move they make is now a digital footprint.”

Noisy town halls made news

APTOPIX Health Care SpecterWere the “liberal” media to blame for health reform’s stumble last month? The Washington Post’s E.J. Dionne thinks so. “I’ve spoken with Democratic House members, most from highly contested districts, about what happened in their town halls,” he wrote. “None would deny polls showing that the health-reform cause lost ground last month, but little of the probing civility that characterized so many of their forums was ever seen on television.” Rep. Chet Edwards, D-Texas, told Dionne he viewed the shouters at his meetings as taking “the Ron Paul libertarian position that represents 2 to 5 percent of the country.”

Remembering the flawed

Obit Ted KennedyThe Boston Globe mentioned Chappaquiddick in the fifth paragraph of its obituary of Sen. Ted Kennedy. The Associated Press and the New York Times waited until the 12th and 15th paragraphs, respectively. Curious about how flawed public figures are eulogized, Philadelphia Inquirer columnist Michael Smerconish looked back and found that Watergate was mentioned by name five paragraphs into the Washington Post’s obituary of President Nixon. “I can’t help but wonder when President Clinton’s obituary will introduce Monica Lewinsky,” he wrote.
“Fox News Sunday” also contrasted the leads of the New York Times’ obituaries of Kennedy last week and Sen. Jesse Helms last year — noting the first was all positive and the latter the opposite, observing that Helms’ “hard-edged conservatism” had targeted civil rights, gay rights, foreign aid and modern art.

Novak left a mark

novakThe death of 78-year-old columnist Robert Novak seems like the end of an era of political reporting and conservative commentary. Some may know him only as the guy who identified Valerie Plame as a CIA agent (and got away with it). But his insider status and corrosive way with words made him a force in national politics and policymaking, as well as the rise of cable news. The editorial board at his home newspaper, the Chicago Sun-Times, recalled this Novak nugget: “Always love your country — but never trust your government!”

Almost McGovern-Cronkite ‘72

cronkiteVice President Walter Cronkite? Frank Mankiewicz, director of Sen. George McGovern’s 1972 presidential campaign, writes in the Washington Post that the idea was discussed but rejected, on the assumption that the CBS newsman would decline. (McGovern eventually went with Missouri Sen. Thomas Eagleton, who withdrew after revelations of his hospitalizations and shock treatments for depression.) According to Mankiewicz, Cronkite told McGovern decades later, “I’d have accepted in a minute; anything to help end that dreadful war.” But would it have mattered? The ticket of McGovern and replacement running mate Sargent Shriver lost to President Nixon 61 to 37 percent.

Time was up on Palin pregnancy jokes

lettermanpalin1The uproar over David Letterman’s unfunny joke about Sarah Palin’s daughter demonstrated that even a deft comedian gets his timing wrong. According to the nonpartisan Center for Media and Public Affairs, the late-night tally of jokes about Bristol Palin’s pregnancy included, as of mid-March: Conan O’Brien, 20; Jay Leno, 15; Letterman, eight; Jon Stewart, four. Some were twofers, joking about the sexual activity of John Edwards and pro hockey players. “Saturday Night Live” even did a joke about incest — just a few weeks before Sarah Palin was a guest on the show. Letterman didn’t help himself by getting his teenage Palins confused in the latest joke. But “why did this one draw such a reaction?” asked Philadelphia Inquirer columnist Michael Smerconish. “Letterman’s timing was waaaay off.”

Obama mania won’t last, matter

obamathumbsup2President Obama has been criticized for being covered too much and too approvingly by the media, a subject pondered Sunday by the roundtable on ABC’s “This Week”:
“Three great love affairs in world history are Abelaid and Heloise, Romeo and Juliet and the American media and this president at the moment,” agreed commentator George Will. “But it doesn’t matter over time. Reality will impinge. If his programs work, he’s fine. If it doesn’t work, all the adulation of journalists in the world won’t help.”
Bill Keller, executive editor of the New York Times, attributed some of the attention to Obama’s “fascinating life story” and status as the first African-American president. “But don’t confuse attention with love,” Keller said. “Here is a new president who has promulgated one huge, ambitious program after another. So of course he gets a lot of big Page One headlines. But I don’t think at least up till now that it’s been unskeptical or uncritical.”

Top 10 things overheard at ‘Fire Letterman’ rally

APTOPIX Letterman PalinDavid Letterman apologized for his joke about Sarah Palin’s daughter, but that didn’t stop him from poking fun at his protesters. His top 10 list Tuesday was on “things overheard at the ‘Fire David Letterman’ rally.” It included:
“Isn’t there always a crowd demanding Letterman be fired?”
“Can we also get CBS to bring back ‘Gunsmoke’?”
“When does Cheney get here with the waterboarding gear?”
“He should apologize for that hairpiece.”

Are conservative media feeding right-wing extremism?

oreillypointing“Today, as in the early years of the Clinton administration but to an even greater extent, right-wing extremism is being systematically fed by the conservative media and political establishment,” columnist Paul Krugman asserts. “Now, for the most part, the likes of Fox News and the RNC haven’t directly incited violence, despite Bill O’Reilly’s declarations that ‘some’ called Dr. Tiller ‘Tiller the Baby Killer,’ that he had ‘blood on his hands,’ and that he was a ‘guy operating a death mill.’ But they have gone out of their way to provide a platform for conspiracy theories and apocalyptic rhetoric, just as they did the last time a Democrat held the White House. And at this point, whatever dividing line there was between mainstream conservatism and the black-helicopter crowd seems to have been virtually erased.”

Ideologues don’t like newspapers

extraextraA House Judiciary Committee hearing last week deteriorated into a press-bashing session in which “ideologues of the left and right made no effort to conceal their yearning for a day without journalists, when public officials would no longer be scrutinized,” wrote Washington Post columnist Dana Milbank. But as University of Pennsylvania law professor C. Edwin Baker told the committee, “the biggest correlator with less government corruption is newspaper readership: When people are reading newspapers, corruption goes down.” That’s why Thomas Jefferson famously said that if asked to choose between “a government without newspapers or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter.”

WE tweet, too

wetweetYou might check out our Twitter page. It has links to We Blog and Opinion page content, plus additional comments and updates. And let us know if you have a page we should follow.

Glenn Beck is ‘mad as hell’ — and audience is happy

beckglennGlenn Beck has had a surge of popularity since becoming a host on Fox News Channel. He is now a leading voice for conservative populist anger, the New York Times reported. Beck says he believes every word he says on his TV and radio shows, though he knows he is also an entertainer. “I’m a rodeo clown,” he said.
Conservative writer David Frum said Beck’s success “is a product of the collapse of conservatism as an organized political force, and the rise of conservatism as an alienated cultural sensibility.”
“It’s a show for people who feel they belong to an embattled minority that is disenfranchised and cut off,” he said.

How much is Jim Cramer to blame?

cramerjim“Just as it takes a village to raise a child, according to the old African proverb, sometimes it takes a comedian to let the emperors of Wall Street journalism know when their clothes are falling apart,” columnist Clarence Page wrote about Jon Stewart’s smackdown of CNBC “Mad Money” host Jim Cramer. But columnist Richard Cohen contends that assigning that much blame to Cramer or other financial journalists is misplaced. “They do not have subpoena power,” he wrote. “They cannot barge into AIG and demand to see the books, and even if they could, they would not have known what they were looking at. The financial instruments that Wall Street firms were both peddling and buying are the functional equivalent of particle physics. To this day, no one knows their true worth.”

Why do most women dislike talk radio?

limbaugh6The conservative Web site New Majority hosted a discussion on why most women don’t like to listen to talk radio. Writer Danielle Crittenden said she doesn’t like the oversize egos of male hosts: “When they weren’t boasting about their moral courage or superior worldviews, they seemed to take everything that was happening politically as a personal slight — or achievement.” Some other commentators suggested that most women may not like the confrontational style of many shows, or they may not be interested in details of politics. But Fox News contributor Margaret Hoover said she likes talk radio because she is a political junkie. “Talk radio is my form of sports talk,” she said.

Right: Fight the power

“It seems to me that the Left has won: utterly and decisively. What I mean is, the ‘Saturday Night Live,’ Jon Stewart, Bill Maher mentality has prevailed. They decide what a person’s image is, and those images stick. They are the ones who say that Cheney’s a monster, W.’s stupid, and Palin’s a bimbo. And the country, apparently, follows,” writes National Review senior editor Jay Nordlinger. To properly push back at the media, entertainment and educational forces that promote such views, he concludes, the conservative “counterestablishment needs to be tended, and beefed up.”