Undocumented cartoonists perform caption-writing chore for Eagle’s slacker artist

My ploy continues to work like a charm. Once again I’ve been able to leave a cartoon unfinished, secure in the knowledge that Dear Readers will do the heavy lifting and provide us with clever captions, performing the kind of jobs that Real Americans like moi turn our noses up at. Wait a minute. Real Americans don’t use sissy French terms like "moi." Oh, well. On to the runners up in the latest caption contest. Click on the image to see this week’s winning entry, then look over these other captions and decide for yourselves whether we’re full of it when it comes to judging such things. Kurt Holmes of Wichita sent in a good caption which was weakened slightly by an unseasonable reference, this being Easter weekend and all: "Next year we’re putting a limit on Thanksgiving guests!" Wichita’s Frank Moore thought of another topic in the news: "See, son. You build a casino and they will come!" Larry England of Medicine Lodge also took a gamble with his caption: "Never trust those white guys. Soon they will want to build a casino close to ours." I really like Tracy McCue of Wellington’s caption, but the other judges didn’t concur: "There, you see what happens when our politicians cater to the ‘lost white guys who think it’s India vote!’" From Kurt Holmes of Wichita: "Son, I suggest they pick the corn this year." Cowboy poet Ed Parrish rustled up this caption: "We’ll watch them for five years. If they work cheap and learn our language, we’ll let them stay." Similarly from Judith White: "We’ll let them stay for 11 years, learn our languages, obey our laws, take only the jobs we don’t want and value what we value." Troy Davis said, "What could possibly go wrong if we just let them all in for their cheap labor? I’m sure they’ll assimilate and learn our language and ways." Here’s a twist fromMadison’s J.V. Shelton: "Well, there goes the neighborhood. My God, is that Fred Phelps waving???" Bruce Cole put a new spin on and old phrase: "Well, here comes the neighborhood!" Bruce also submitted "Maybe these men can help us build a wall to keep people out of our land." That one was similar to the winner’s caption, but we gave the winner points for brevity. Richard Julius, always prolific, sent lots of captions. Among the best were "Are they waving at us with one finger???" and "Hopefully, this is just a cruise ship!" Another caption I liked better than my fellow judges was from Sandra Cay of Wichita: "Iraq’s the other way!" Wichita’s Karen Wallace had several good ones: "At last the gardeners have arrived!" and "The work they won’t do, we’ll outsource to India!" and a pretty good pun: "More will come. They get 3,000 miles to the galleon!" Bernie Lantz of Bel Aire said, "We stop immigration, we never get to watch American Idol!" And finally, a few shots a me. An anonymous chap included a note which read: "Hey, Rich, let’s see ya publish this one, you liberal apologist! Only a liberal would compare the original immigrants to this country with the floods of illegals who now invade." And his or her caption: "Look, my son…a new way of life is here! Improved medicine, technology, industry, housing! Thank God!" Then from P.A. Lawrence of Mulvane: " Now get-um straight-um. No talk-um about Hopi cannibalism, Apache running buffalo over cliff for meat and NEVER tell them about plains Indian raids taking women slaves. They’ll think we are SAVAGES! Remember ‘we are one with the earth.’ In 500 years a so-called cartoonist CROWSON will spin history to meet our needs!"
Posted by Richard Crowson

4 Comments

  1. flike
    Posted April 17, 2006 at 9:57 am | Permalink

    At the risk of leading this thread astray, the last couple responses remind me of the Thanksgiving of about 1996 or so when my brother, the central Kansas hermit, crank, and total gun nut (he’s basically tame if only occasionally housebroken) disagreed vehemently with my casual dinner observation that white Americans had broken every treaty ever signed with American Indians.

    Nothing like opening up a can of worms at a turkey dinner.

    My brother imnmediately recited exactly the same list as Mulvane’s Mr. Lawrence, plus something like “American Indians were responsible for the slaughter of far more American Indians than whites ever were.”

    This was back in the day when blog gladiators were just a gleam in the eye of most sane adults and I remember thinking “how the heck did he come up with that list so fast? Has he been practicing this?”

    Somewhere out there, in some place other than freerepublic.com, there exists a whole other narrative of just about every known fact most of us take for granted, having learned most such facts in public school.

    I don’t claim this as news since I’m sure most Americans by now are aware that we have 2 varying, often contradictory, versions of every news story published.

    I sure like your cartoons, Mr. Crowson, fwiw.

  2. Ben Huie
    Posted April 17, 2006 at 10:34 am | Permalink

    “”American Indians were responsible for the slaughter of far more American Indians than whites ever were.”"

    Which explains why there were almost no Indians here; why there were no Cherokee cities; why they were all already herded into concentration camps. NOT!

  3. Darwin'sDisciple
    Posted April 17, 2006 at 6:03 pm | Permalink

    flike,There is nothing like encountering those alternate universes at those family gatherings.

    You expect that kind of thing here.

  4. Disappointed, as usual
    Posted April 25, 2006 at 8:06 pm | Permalink

    I’m just glad that I hadn’t submitted an entry on this one. It was a very difficult cartoon to come up with a good caption for and it appears that the judge/judges decided to play it safe and not go with anything close to being a controversial caption. What could you expect, given the cartoon and the timing. This comes as no surprise.

    I would have given my nod to Bruce Cole on this one, but I still think that there should be a limit of one “best” entry submission.