Monthly Archives: March 2006

Open thread


Move over, Hester Prynne

"Anybody that votes for an amnesty bill deserves to be branded with a scarlet letter, ‘A’ for amnesty, and they need to pay for it at the ballot box in November," Rep. Steve King, R-Iowa, ranted at a House Republican gathering Thursday. But the Senate immigration bill — which Sen. Sam Brownback, R-Kan., supports — seems a reasonable balance between dealing with security concerns and with the reality that we are not going to deport 12 million illegal immigrants. Nor could our economy handle that. The bill would increase border enforcement and penalties for employers who hire illegal workers. And in order to become a U.S. citizens, current immigrants would have to be here 11 years, have a clean record and a steady job, pay a $2,000 fine and back taxes, and understand English and U.S. civics.
As Sen. Arlen Specter, R-Pa., noted: "This word ‘amnesty’ is a code word. It is a code word to try to smear good-faith legislation."
Posted by Phillip Brownlee

No war on chaplains

Some religious conservatives are claiming that military chaplains aren’t allowed to pray in Jesus’ name. But, no surprise, that’s way overstated.
The policy announced last month asks that chaplains give nonsectarian prayers in “command functions” in which soldiers of many faiths are encouraged or required to attend. It doesn’t apply to religious services or other functions. Sounds reasonable. But some conservatives in Congress are asking for — and religious broadcasters are demanding — a presidential order guaranteeing the right of chaplains to pray in the name of Jesus.
Such an order is not needed and is based on “confusion and misinformation,” the Rev. Herman Keizer Jr., chairman of the National Conference on Ministry to the Armed Forces, which represents more than 70 percent of military chaplains, told The Washington Post. “This has been portrayed as though chaplains are not allowed to pray in Jesus’ name, without any distinction between what they do all the time in worship services and what they do occasionally, in ceremonial settings where attendance is mandatory,” Keizer said.
Posted by Phillip Brownlee

Adults-only video games should be only for adults

Most adults probably assumed that video stores are already prohibited from selling or renting to minors games rated “mature” and “adults only.” They’re not. To his credit, Sen. Sam Brownback, R-Kan., hopes to change that by encouraging state legislatures to pass restrictions. But a bill proposed by state Rep. Jim Ward, D-Wichita, to ban such sales to minors hasn’t even had a committee hearing this session. Why not?
In the end, of course, it’s up to parents to act like parents and not let their children play inappropriate video games. And, no, playing a violent video game doesn’t mean that a teen will go on a shooting rampage. But it is reasonable and responsible to expect that games rated for adults only are sold only to adults.
Posted by Phillip Brownlee

Get the details right now on anti-picketing bill, or pay later

Maybe any legislation aimed at curbing the appalling protests of military funerals by Fred Phelps’ clan would invite legal challenges on free speech grounds, no matter the details. Still, it’s regrettable that the Kansas House’s unanimously passed measure neglected the Senate’s more thoughtful language. As negotiators try to reconcile the House’s 300-yard buffer and the Senate’s 100-yard buffer, as well as other differences, they should be sensitive to what lawmakers’ zeal to limit these protests could end up costing taxpayers later in legal fees. And they can consider themselves warned by Shirley Phelps-Roper, Phelps’ daughter: “The U.S. Supreme Court has spoken on this issue, and they can’t put us out of sight and sound of our targeted audience. If they don’t like what they see, they need to drink a frosty mug of shut-the-hell-up and avert their eyes.”
Posted by Rhonda Holman

Selective time management at Legislature

Both The Eagle and the Lawrence Journal-World have done articles this week about the Kansas Chamber of Commerce’s new push, including full-page newspaper ads, for legislation to prevent Kansas from becoming “a hotbed for frivolous asbestos lawsuits.” Even the chamber notes these suits aren’t a problem in Kansas. Some have wondered if Wichita’s Koch Industries — which recently purchased Georgia-Pacific, a defendant in several asbestos lawsuits — is behind the effort (chamber president S. Lewis Ebert denies any connection).
Rep. Candy Ruff, D-Leavenworth, couldn’t help but be struck by the contrast between the attention given this bill and the inattention given one taking Wal-Mart to task over its employee benefits. “Let me get this straight: We don’t have time for a bill that would have told Wal-Mart to quit dumping its employees’ health insurance on the state? But we do have time for a bill that as far as anybody knows doesn’t affect anybody in Kansas?” Ruff marveled to the Journal-World.
Posted by Rhonda Holman

Ryun’s house deal smells fishy

Rep. Jim Ryun, R-Topeka, denies that he got a sweetheart deal on his Washington, D.C., townhouse, but it does smell fishy. Ryun paid the U.S. Family Network $410,000 for the house in 2000, $19,000 less than the group paid for it two years earlier. Ryun has said that he paid less because of some structural problems. But the real estate market was rapidly rising at the time (and the house is currently assessed at $764,310).
A big part of the suspicion is the sleaziness of U.S. Family Network. The nonprofit group was founded by Ed Buckham, an evangelical minister and former chief of staff to Rep. Tom DeLay, R-Texas. It was funded almost entirely by corporations linked to former lobbyist and now convicted felon Jack Abramoff, and more than a third of that money — $1 million — went to Buckham and his wife, The Washington Post reported.
Posted by Phillip Brownlee

Carroll’s happy ending stands out amid violence

How remarkable that freelance reporter Jill Carroll was released unharmed in Baghdad, after three months of captivity and those heart-wrenching videotape appeals. “They never hit me. They never even threatened to hit me,” she said on Iraqi TV. Sadly, Carroll’s happy ending does not appear to be a sign of any trend away from violence in the country. According to U.S. Maj. Gen. Rick Lynch, the Iraqi casualties have soared in the past few weeks, to a daily average of about 75 dead and wounded. That rate is higher than the past two years.
Posted by Rhonda Holman

Why can’t FISA oversee?

Sen. Pat Roberts, R-Kan., argued in a commentary in Sunday’s Eagle that the National Security Agency’s secret wiretapping program is needed to protect homeland security. But why can’t the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act court oversee the program to make sure the wiretapping is legal and justified?
Five former FISA judges argued before the Senate Judiciary Committee this week for just such a role, The New York Times reported. The judges also warned that the program could imperil criminal prosecutions that grew out of the wiretaps. And Harold A. Baker, who served on the FISA court until last year, said the president was bound by the law “like everyone else,” and that “the president ignores it at the president’s peril.”
Posted by Phillip Brownlee

Political promises outstripping economic reality

“The dilemma of advanced democracies, including the United States, is that they’ve made more promises than they can keep,” Washington Post columnist Robert J. Samuelson wrote about the labor protests in France. “Their political commitments outstrip the economy’s capacity to deliver.” And the political dilemma, he notes, is that “to disavow past promises incites public furor; not to disavow them worsens the country’s future problems.”
Hence, Congress still hasn’t reformed Social Security.
Posted by Phillip Brownlee

Hensley doing better job representing Wichita than some in our delegation

Sedgwick County finally has a state lawmaker going to bat for the majority of its citizens who want to vote on a local casino. And, of course, he’s not from here. Senate Minority Leader Anthony Hensley, D-Topeka, wants to let Sedgwick County residents decide for themselves whether they want expanded gaming, and in what form. “Up until now, they’ve been stifled by their own County Commission at the insistence of Sedgwick County legislators,” he said. But count on those local lawmakers to do their best to block Hensley and the will of the public.
Posted by Phillip Brownlee

Forget schools; some don’t want these weapons used anywhere

Something to consider in the wake of the use of a Taser on a Wichita North High School student this month: More than 150 people in the country have died in the past five years after being shocked by the weapons, according to Amnesty International, which seeks a moratorium on their use by police. Let it also be said that the manufacturer’s Web site offers lots of anecdotal evidence about the Taser’s ability to save lives. Clearly, the nation is still deciding what to make of this new high-tech weaponry.
Posted by Rhonda Holman

Important intersection, important art

Not everybody on the Wichita City Council had a favorable first impression Tuesday of the $150,000 light sculpture proposed for the Rock Road overpass at Kellogg. That’s not surprising. By definition, art and design strike each viewer differently. Part of the success of Wichita’s 16-year public art program has been its breadth, from traditional to contemporary. As council members take another month to consider the design, by artist Todd Whipple in collaboration with Dan Gegen and Chris Frank, they may better understand what prompted the 15 professionals on the city’s volunteer Art and Design Review Board to give the sculpture their unanimous approval. Wichita will make a lasting statement about itself in how it chooses to adorn and enhance such a visible intersection.
Posted by Rhonda Holman

Lose the Mexican flags

Memo to the immigrant-rights marchers: Whatever the merits of your case, it’s a big mistake to wave so many Mexican flags, which in the Los Angeles march appeared to outnumber U.S. flags. The message many Americans will receive is, “We’ve been invaded by people whose allegiance is to Mexico.” That’s not a winning strategy for gaining their support.
Posted by Randy Scholfield

Let the evacuation of Kabul begin

It’s a relief that Abdul Rahman made it out of that gulaglike nightmare that is “liberated” Afghanistan. The man who was threatened with death, either from the courts or mobs, for converting to Christianity has received asylum in Italy, according to reports.
This could be a new mission for U.S. troops in Afghanistan — evacuating people who want religious liberty.
Posted by Randy Scholfield

While we’re worked up about border control

How scary to learn this week that in December, congressional investigators smuggled radioactive material in the trunks of rental cars across borders with Canada and Mexico. It was no comfort that the radiation alarms went off, either, because phony documents were sufficient to persuade U.S. Customs and Border Protection inspectors that the cargo should get through anyway.
Glad it was only a test. Next time, though, it could be the makings of a dirty bomb.
Posted by Rhonda Holman

Newest state law will save lives

The new law requiring 4- through 7-year-olds to ride in booster seats will come as a bothersome surprise to some parents come July 1. But under the law, which Gov. Kathleen Sebelius signed Monday, only warnings will be issued for the first year, and after that, an errant parent can have his fine waived by getting a booster seat. Most important: More kids riding with proper restraints will mean fewer injuries and deaths in accidents. “It’s absolutely the right thing,” state Sen. Les Donovan, R-Wichita, said four years ago. And now, thanks in part to his tenacity, it’s also the law.
Posted by Rhonda Holman

Act up, lose your news

The U.S. Supreme Court is considering whether states can make prison inmates’ access to newspapers and magazines conditional on their good behavior. Things being what they are in print journalism these days, we’re all for viewing newspapers as a reward, even if just for a captive readership. But who knew newspapers could also be so easily turned into lethal weapons? (Certain violent prisoners did, according to Pennsylvania’s executive deputy attorney general.)
The issue is serious. An inmate argued withholding his Christian Science Monitor violated his First Amendment rights; Pennsylvania argued that such rights-restricting “behavior modification” is OK as long as it’s for a legitimate reason and the alternatives are exhausted.
Posted by Rhonda Holman

Lott committed to the cause?

Does Sen. Trent Lott, R-Miss., think ethics reform is funny? Post-Abramoff, it isn’t. But Lott, chairman of the Senate Rules Committee, recently joked of changes that would include barring lawmakers from accepting meals or gifts from lobbyists: “We would give up any pay, any outside food. We would live in the Russell compound. We would have no conjugal visits. And for 15 minutes a day we would go out into the courtyard, which we would use to confess our sins and flagellate ourselves.” This week, as the Senate prepared to work on the bill, Lott cautioned, “This is an intricate dance we’re in.” If Lott’s trying not to get ethics reformers’ hopes too high, he’s doing a fine job.
Posted by Rhonda Holman

More Republicans doubting Bush foreign policy

Democrats aren’t the only ones questioning the Bush administration’s foreign policy aim of spreading democracy. With violence and costs in Iraq increasing and a newly elected Hamas government in the region, more Republicans are voicing doubts as to whether this foreign policy is realistic.
“You cannot in my opinion just impose a democratic form of government on a country with no history and no culture and no tradition of democracy,” Sen. Chuck Hagel, R-Neb., recently told The New York Times.
But Bush hasn’t been one to let dissent get in the way of his goals. And Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice told the Times that this administration would again stick to its goals.
Posted by Melissa Cooley

One way to say ‘give it up’

Joking and lawmaking don’t mix, but credit Rep. Dale Swenson, R-Wichita, for creativity in suggesting Rep. Becky Hutchins, R-Holton, had taken up enough time with her serial attempts to repeal the immigrant in-state tuition law. At one point last week, Swenson pursued a measure to rename a portion of U.S. 75 in Hutchins’ district after the late Mexican-American activist Cesar Chavez. Swenson’s amendment didn’t get a vote, but his point was made.
Posted by Rhonda Holman

Card going away

So many people of all political persuasions were calling for fresh ideas at the White House that it hardly seemed surprising when White House chief of staff Andrew Card resigned today. It sends a good message that the president is willing to try something new in response to his sagging poll numbers, rather than resist change. That said, why promote budget director Josh Bolten? Maybe he’s a great, loyal, competent guy, but that just reminds everybody of what a budget buster this administration and Congress have been. And, why, oh, why, can’t the one who goes ever be the one who really deserves to go, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld?
Posted by Rhonda Holman

Let them feel it in their wallets

Sen. George Allen, R-Va., one of the many Republicans pondering the presidency, has made a provocative suggestion for how to keep members of Congress from blowing their budget deadline every year: Withhold their paychecks. “There’s a great need for fiscal responsibility in Washington,” he said. “It’s absurd that a full-time legislature at the Capitol can’t get their job done by October 1st. There is no excuse why this can’t get done on time.” Of course, note Allen’s critics, timing isn’t everything: The senator was among those who recently voted to raise the federal debt ceiling to $9 trillion.
Posted by Rhonda Holman

Creekstone has a legitimate beef

Creekstone Farms is suing the U.S. Department of Agriculture for refusing to allow the Arkansas City processor to test all its beef for mad cow disease. Creekstone wants to exceed federal and industry testing practices to ease the fears of skittish foreign customers such as the Japanese.
The issue is not whether blanket testing is necessary to ensure safety — everyone, including Creekstone, agrees it’s not — but whether a company should be able to go above and beyond federal guidelines to meet the needs of its customers.
Why shouldn’t it be able to do that?
Posted by Randy Scholfield

When Saddam wasn’t home for the shock and awe

Were Russian President Vladimir Putin’s eyes lying when President Bush famously looked into them and liked what he saw? The world got another reason to wonder last week, with the news of an American military report that Russian spies passed information to Iraq about the 2003 invasion and U.S. troop movements. Even if the report is accurate, that doesn’t mean Putin or other top Russian leaders were involved; Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice is right to try to find out. But none of this bodes well for U.S-Russia cooperation on Iran’s nuclear ambitions.
Posted by Rhonda Holman