Comments on: Idol history is made

By: lbm

lbm — Fri, 08 May 2009 19:43:37 +0000

Well, I finally had to comment. First time this season. I seem to remember a lot of bloggers making the same kind of predictions about who couldn’t possibly win last season so I think I will wait and see who actually wins and not take any of your prophetic words to heart. Second, there are a lot of people who enjoy a voice like Kris’ as well as one like Adam’s. I am one of them. And I too would buy a CD by Kris but would probably never buy one by Adam. ( I did get David Cooks’, my secret pleasure.) As for the show this season, I will definitely say that I have spent much more time fast-forwarding through sooo much extraneous garbage from those double-talking judges. Ridiculous, I say! Oh yeah, why hasn’t anyone mentioned how badly Danny messed up the lyrics during the duet! No wonder Kris was mad.

By: idol worshipper

idol worshipper — Fri, 08 May 2009 15:51:17 +0000

me, too… i didn’t know No Doubt, either, but had heard of Gwen Stefani. she sure can move fast! maybe faster than she needed to. kinda like an exercise video.
i am still trying to get over that song that was performed a couple of weeks ago (i can’t even bring myself to write the name of it down here!) which made an obvious reference to a type of sex act. what was idol thinking????? part of the lyric is “my head spins around when you go —- —-”. well, let me tell ya, my head spun around a little when i realized what they were saying.

By: Monica

Monica — Fri, 08 May 2009 06:12:37 +0000

boobookitty, I had no idea who No Doubt was either and although I had heard of Gwen Stefani, it wasn’t until my niece said it was her performing that I put 2 and 2 together. I was really glad I didn’t let her know how woefully out of date I am by oommenting on her on my family idol blog lol!

Ok…one thing I didn’t mention and just cannot let go. Who decided it was a good idea to give Kara woody woodpecker hair on Tuesday night and let her big ears stick out? We all have flaws but I’m thinking there must be some stylist on the Idol payroll who wanted a payback to Kara to make her look so bad Tuesday.

By: Pauleygirl

Pauleygirl — Thu, 07 May 2009 22:39:48 +0000

I liked Allison alot too but knew she wouldnt win. That fact is obvious. I don’t feel too bad for her though. She’s gained some awesome experience and exposure and if she’s got what it takes, she’ll make it. I really like Kris. He just seems so genuine and of the three left I can say I would be more inclined to purchase his cd than any of the others. I liked Danny in the beginning but I have lost interest. Adam definately has been fun to watch and kept my interest piqued to see what he’s going to do each week, but I know I could never listen to him thru a whole CD. The whole American Idol experience this year has been pretty crappy though as far as production of the show goes. From the stupid babbling of the judges pushing the show past its time slot to the stupid production numbers and stage falling apart as it did on tues this week just before the show. Oh well…it will all be over soon.

By: Rick

Rick — Thu, 07 May 2009 22:18:25 +0000

I’ll like Adam a lot better after his voice changes. Yes, he can really carry a tune, but I didn’t like the high-pitched lead singers in the 80’s hair bands and I haven’t changed my mind since. Too bad for Allison, though – I liked her a lot.

By: boobookitty

boobookitty — Thu, 07 May 2009 21:57:33 +0000

AJET – honey child – I’m a baby boomer. Sorry not up do date on today’s weirdos.

By: Cathygr

Cathygr — Thu, 07 May 2009 17:53:06 +0000

oh yes, forgot about Miss Paula, I thought she did just great, and the camera man did a fairly decent job hiding the lip synching this time, she still has it, and if I was 25 years younger and still hanging out at the dance clubs, this song would be playing I’m pretty sure! Danny did handle himself pretty well, have to grant him that, I think he was prepared to go home.

By: AJET

AJET — Thu, 07 May 2009 17:32:23 +0000

To boobookitty…. Really? You really don’t know who No Doubt or Gwen Stefani are/is? I hope you were born after the year 1995…. Please tell me you were.

By: Hum...

Hum... — Thu, 07 May 2009 16:47:38 +0000

I had totally braced myself to see Kris or Danny go home. I feel bad that Allison had to leave, but its ok she still gets to tour and who knows..she may get a record deal out of the thing.

And OMG wasn’t Daughtry awesome? I love them!

By: idol worshipper

idol worshipper — Thu, 07 May 2009 16:14:15 +0000

adam is the winner in my book, no matter what happens. his ability to sing transcends musical genre. he can sing anything and be better than the other singers on ai this season or any other season so far. if he wore a plaid shirt and said “awe, shucks”, would middle america be more likely to vote for him? if he loses, it will be a case of perception of who he is and not of his talent. which would be a shame.