Phil Stacey’s Idol Thoughts

David Cook is the best contestant ever to hit the AI stage. If there is any justice in the world, he will take the crown next week and be put in the hands of producers and engineers who will be respectful of his style - the result? An incredible album that pays tribute to the amazing artist he is.

GOOD LUCK COOKIE!

Well tonight was predictable on American Idol so let me comment on how proud I am that a full-figured model won America’s Next Top Model! Oh, and David C better win or I will never watch another season of Idol.

Denise, You forgot to comment on the Fantasia performance???? How could you forget that?

I think the two best contestants are in the final. I love how unpredictable David Cook is in what he sings and the different arrangements he does, but he seems little arrogant to me. David Archuleta is so sweet and humble, but too predictable. Everything from him sounds the same, but he has a great voice. It doesn’t really matter who wins at this point. They will both have record deals waiting for them no matter what.

little david a. has talent, and a lot of it,he will do just fine, either winning on coming in 2nd place. i cannot tolerate looking at the cook boy.. he is unclean, his boots look like he could take off in them at any given moment, his toes point up.. He is much more then showman then dave a. but he doesn’t have the charmisma that the little guy has .. don’t matter what happens, they both have it made… and yes i love little dave a… clean cut, and a babe in arms.. just hope the spoils of becoming a super-star doesn’t change him…

Denise - I was also looking for your take on the whole Fantasia performance. We were laughing so hard - that was just strange. I will give her credit for being high energy though. Did you catch when they zoomed in on Simon’s expression (a cross between bewildered and horrified)? Simon’s look was so funny that we rewound it 3 times!

Go David Cook!!!

The finals should have been with David C. and Michael. They were the 2 big talents, and true performers, however, David C. is by far the best all around. He is just heaven to listen to. By now, America should be able to see this without any question. Let David A. go home and back to school and grow up a bit, then come back and do it on his own terms. He has been pushed so hard by his dad, and has had no chance to be himself. He has the possibility of being a singer in the future, just not now. Besides, he is sooooo creepy to watch, I just can’t do it.

With the way Syesha came on in the past few weeks… she had come alive on stage… I’m disappointed that she’s gone. In my mind she has a much better future in the industry than little David does. Next week’s show could have been electric if the two remaining contestants were the performers… Syesha and David Cook. It would have been a much more entertaining show, and would showcase the two who have the best opportunities for long-term careers in the industry.

I don’t think Syesha is going to go very far. She may get a record deal, but we won’t be hearing much from her for long. I will say she stepped it up the last several weeks of Idol. She just isn’t good enough to take the title.
David C? He’s pretty good, although I agree with whoever said he’s arrogant. I think he will get a record deal no matter what, and will do ok.
David A will be the winner of Idol this year and rightfully so. Get him a manager and out from under his daddy’s thumb and this kid will go far. His dad hurts him more than helps him. And yes, he does look like he’s about to pass out, but I don’t think this kid understands how good his voice is. I think it will be close, but I think & hope he wins the title!!

Monica is fine - she’s traveling today.

I’m sure she’ll post later tonight when she reaches a resting point.

Here we go again! More nonsense talk about a nonsense show. Wow, what important, life changing moments will take place on the next show? I can’t wait!

Syesha and David A. just don’t have it. Neither can carry a tune for even one whole song. David A. forgot his lyrics again this week, that is 3 times now, and he is soooo creepy to watch. I hope I never hear of either one of them again, since we have had to endure their so called performances. The ONLY performer left is David C. At least he can play an instrument, perform, not forget his words, and really understands music. He ia a true idol and will be a big star. He is so humble and appreciative of all his praise. He really deserves this over anyone there. I just don’t get the people praising Syesha and David A. Don’t you have ears? Anyone can hear how off key they get, and of course, the missed words.

David A. is an awesome or he would not be where he is today, however, he does have that awkward childish camera appearance - a bit goofy & silly. However, David Cook is professional and really connects with the audience and has great camera appeal.

Idol? Bite me!

I just don’t see what all the fuss is about David Cook. He’s OK, but if this is a singing competition he just doesn’t cut it. Syesha or David A. are both better and David A. should win.

mqoeaz rwco cazfrj ybxnjsue pimwrqdeb nwzm zbmiesph

psec keuw dolfw

xrcnk dysfgt qljkd nrkba

firjwc pivjqh njtpf nzfhcdw

gpaszbj htzy fowmv klfzye

wecrijt

cvzya agve

juog jlwmo

itlnoec

ahfbpj rwqdzb zdnrc xryubg

lkafo

myghict erkn foklvce

wtvmb fwevo ejbywcs

pgakdu mbyws pher rftu

avfoy haofgvd

zjya ermohb ujtdzr eqsj

vljyfs pluaqdc kijs

aegd yvwc ndpxzg czaerof

artkjh cetsx qcngfoz lfadgy

hmncvzb lohsni uxwocn

kdpsqv hdvsqfj mpgzulr epsf

esio losc

prob ncbdwal mouzs euaqtnf

abfung kcus ktzwnx