Some cute girls, huh? And even a few who can sing.
My first-night impression from American Idol is that one of three women _ Katharine 
McPhee, Lisa Tucker and Paris Bennett _ are going to reach the finals. I don’t see any way for anyone else to sneak into the competition. They’re all too good, far and away the best of the 12 who participated 
on Tuesday night’s show.
I’m really pulling for Kellie Pickler because she’s such a down-to-earth, sweet girl who has been through a lot of difficult times. I wanted her to win from the first time I saw her. She might go on to do things in the music world, but she’s out of her league in this competition. Sorry to say.
I have a soft spot for Melissa McGhee, who looks like a girl I had a crush on in high school. I have often wondered what happened to that girl. I wonder if she wonders about me? Sorry, doing a little daydreaming there. Anyway, McGhee is cute, but not one of the best singers.
Most of the women are really likable. But unless somebody shows something they didn’t show Tuesday night, it’s a three-woman race.
Here’s the order of finish after Round 1:
1. Katharine McPhee
1a. Paris Bennett
1b. Lisa Tucker
4. Mandisa
5. Kellie Pickler
6. Kinnik Sky
7. Ayla Brown
8. Melissa McGhee
9. Becky O’Donohue
10. Brenna Gethers
11. Heather Cox
12. Stevie Scott
Stevie, you’re going home.
2 Comments
In your order Stevie AND Heather are going home. Remember it’s the bottom two.
I really wanna know how everyone feels about Brenna. I don’t care for her. Does anyone enjoy her attitude?
I agree with you on the top 4 and on Kellie. And I think that Heather and Stevie are going home. I really like Mandisa, she’s not the best in the group but I’m still really rooting for her, and anyone that can sing Heart like that has some intestinal fortitude. I could do without Brenna’s attitude but got to admit she’s a little firecracker. Can’t wait to watch the guys tonight. I’m expecting great things out of them.